Debate rages over whether race had Function in police Reaction to Capitol riot

When many facts remain to be sorted out roughly how countless rioters captured authorities off guard and stormed the country's Capitol building last month, African American studies professor Mark Anthony Neal stated recent history indicates that had the great number of marauders been Black Lives Issue protesters the law enforcement reaction could have been quite different.

Debate rages over whether race had Function in police Reaction to Capitol riot

When many facts remain to be sorted out roughly how countless rioters captured authorities off guard and stormed the country's Capitol building last month, African American studies professor Mark Anthony Neal stated recent history indicates that had the great number of marauders been Black Lives Issue protesters the law enforcement reaction could have been quite different.

TheEditor
TheEditor
23 February 2021 Tuesday 14:38
98 Reads
Debate rages over whether race had Function in police Reaction to Capitol riot

Citing the high amount of force used in response to largely peaceful Black Lives Issue demonstrations across the summer and spring in Washington, D.C., the Duke University academic stated that"these protesters could have never gotten near the Capitol at the manner that we watched those white protesters on January 6"

"What we find is that Black people only and individuals of color just don't have the latitude to behave openly.

Over a month following the Capitol insurrection left four people dead, including Capitol Police Officer Brian Sisknick, and over 50 police officers wounded, the argument rages over whether race played an essential part in empowering the largely white mob -- supposedly whipped into a frenzy from former President Donald Trump's debunked asserts the November election was stolen by him -- to overrun the safety of this nation's most visible chair of democracy.

"When Black folks protest for our own lives, we're often fulfilled by National Guard troops or authorities armed with assault rifles, shields, tear gas and combat helmets," the Dark Lives Issue Global Network Foundation said in a statement. "When white men and women try a coup, they're met through an underwhelming variety of law enforcement employees who behave powerless to intervene, going so far as to present for selfies with terrorists"

In a long statement published a day following the Capitol Building takeover, Sund seemed to blame the incident on breakdowns in safety planning, policies and processes. But he said nothing about if an evaluation is going to also looking at the way in which the race of the rioters also played a role.

"Make no mistake -- those mass riots weren't First Amendment actions; they had been criminal riotous behaviour," Sund said in his announcement. "The activities of this USCP officers were epic granted the situation they confronted, and that I continue to have enormous respect from the dedication and professionalism of these men and women of the United States Capitol Police."

The Senate will maintain its initial public hearing about the Capitol insurrection on Tuesday.

Critics claim that the stark contrast between the huge law enforcement reaction to current BLM protests in Washington, D.C., along with its poor performance throughout the Capitol riots is proof of this double standard they allege are available not only in the country's capital but in police agencies throughout the nation.

"And definitely one of the reasons for this was the various racial makeup of the audiences at these 2 protests along with the distinct specific aims and grievances of these audiences."

As tens of thousands of people of colour took to the roads last year to protest the passing of George Floyd, a 46-year-old Black guy who died on May 25 after authorities in Minneapolis trapped him into the floor and just dug his knee at the trunk of Floyd's throat, law enforcement officers have regularly clashed with demonstrators despite signs revealing nearly all the protests were peaceful. On occasion, authorities deployed tear gas and rubber bullets, bruising bodies and faces with batons.

By the time of Floyd's passing to Aug. 22, there were over 10,600 demonstration events throughout the nation and almost 95 percent were calm, as stated by the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED), a nonprofit group that monitors political violence and protests. Greater than 570 protests -- or about 5 percent -- entailed demonstrators participating in violence, ACLED reported.

Regardless of the signs that BLM protests were largely peaceful, at least 40 cities throughout the nation enforced curfews and National Guard members have been triggered in 15 countries and in Washington, D.C.

By contrast, 316 individuals, or twice as numerous, were detained at a largely calm June 1 Black Lives Issue protest in D.C., along with hundreds of National Guard troops were deployed into the city, many of these assigned to shield domestic monuments and monuments.

ABC News contributor Brad Garrett, a retired FBI agent and terrorism and crime analyst, also noted that the Capitol Police said that they had intellect the audience expected in the Jan. 6"Save America" rally may flip unruly. In an interview with the Washington Post, Sund maintained he voiced concerns to the House Sergeant-at-Arms and proposed deploying the National Guard ahead of the rally, but had been rebuffed because of issues with the"optics" of announcing a crisis before the rally.

"For whatever reason, the choice had been left to, in my opinion, set the Capitol Police to neglect.

Throughout the January insurrection, tens of thousands of Trump fans, largely white, marched out of a campaign-style rally, where the then-president invited them to"fight like hell," into the Capitol Building and broke into lawmakers, such as then-Vice President Mike Pence, were convening to reevaluate the Democratic votes, forcing elected officials and personnel to shield in place.

In contrast, Garrett remembered a June 1 incident where police used tear gas and pepper spray to disperse a crowd of calm BLM protesters before the White House so that Trump could walk into St. John's Church and maintain a Bible to get a photo-op.

"The case in Black Lives Issue and case in the Capitol are equally massive failures for law enforcement," Garrett explained.

Pressman added the Capitol riot came up to 700 people, many carrying firearms, swarmed the state Capitol Building in Lansing, Michigan, in April with minimal resistance from the authorities to demand a stop to Gov. Gretchen Whitmer's stay-at-home orders enforced to fight the COVID-19 pandemic.

"The riots on January 6 were some type of crowning second, on lots of occasions, that were pointing in precisely the exact same way," Pressman said.

Neal, the Duke University professor, stated that during U.S. history heaps of peaceful protests between Black individuals are fulfilled with a disproportionate police answer.

"When we discuss the genius of Martin Luther King, beyond his oratory, however, understanding that nonviolent protests were likely to be broadcast across the globe... they always knew that law enforcement will react as quickly as they did and attract attention to how these people were protesting nonviolently but nevertheless they had been treated in violent manners."

He said that a huge gap between the 1960s Civil Rights Movement and the Black Lives Issue protests is that today everybody has a phone camera and can place in real time any overreaction by authorities in efforts to quell BLM protests. He explained that in 2017, authorities in Ferguson, Missouri, reacted in armored vehicles and army equipment to crush protests on the deadly police officer shooting Michael Brown, a Black teenager.

"The Ferguson bit was very important because you have to see the floor the manner that protesters were tear-gassed," Neal said. "We did not need to see newsreel footageas we did during the Civil Rights Movement."

Much like in Ferguson and elsewhere,'' Neal reported the Capitol riot has throw scrutiny on the disparities in law enforcement's response to uprisings dependent on the colour of these participated in unrest.

"For most white Americans, it was as though they'd only discovered white supremacy existed, that white supremacy can be closely connected to law authorities, our military forces," Neal said. "This really is something which people who were fighting white supremacy and coping with anti-racist politics have understood."

Pressman added that he considers that the comparisons have been made between the treatment of BLM protesters along with the Capitol insurrectionist has compelled several white Americans to rethink their complacency to look another way.

"It shakes their own openness to forget what to these may have previously been more subtle signals of the racism that is baked in to U.S. history," he explained.

Keywords:
Capitol
Comments

Warning!

You have to login for comment. If you are not a member? Register now.

Login Sign Up